In Axia Growth's analysis of closed small-business sales, insurance agencies are grouped in the Financial Services sector, where businesses with $10M+ of EBITDA sold for a median 9.0x EBITDA (middle half 5.7x-14.4x) across 96 sales, updated October 28, 2026. According to MarshBerry, average upfront insurance agency valuations were 11.50x EBITDA at Q4 2025, rising to 15.48x with the maximum earnout.
Independent insurance agency M&A is slowing but still dominated by private capital. OPTIS Partners counted 292 U.S. and Canadian agency deals in the first half of 2026, the slowest start since 2016. MarshBerry found private-capital-backed buyers behind 74.4% of announced U.S. deals through July, and an average upfront price of 11.50x EBITDA at end-2025 (15.48x with maximum earnout). With commercial premiums now falling, buyers pay most for agencies that grow through new business rather than rate increases.
Why published multiples differ
Published multiples differ mostly because they use different earnings and deal sizes. Small, owner-run businesses (under $2M of earnings) are priced on SDE, seller's discretionary earnings, which adds back the owner's pay, so SDE multiples are lower. From $2M of earnings up, buyers price on EBITDA, and multiples rise with size. Averages that mix sizes, or quote larger private-equity deals, read higher than a small-business sale.
Multiples by deal size
Sector: Financial Services. Median and middle half (p25-p75) of sale price to earnings.
Closed small-business sales in the Financial Services sector, by deal size. Axia Growth analysis of closed small-business sales, updated October 28, 2026.
Size band
n
Median multiple
p25-p75
Basis
Under $500K SDE
70
3.7x
2.8x-8.5x
SDE
$500K-$1M SDE
27
6.0x
4.0x-19.1x
SDE
$1M-$2M SDE
46
9.4x
5.1x-16.0x
SDE
$2M-$3M EBITDA
29
11.0x
8.3x-13.5x
EBITDA
$3M-$5M EBITDA
33
9.1x
5.6x-12.7x
EBITDA
$5M-$10M EBITDA
51
9.8x
6.1x-13.6x
EBITDA
$10M+ EBITDA
96
9.0x
5.7x-14.4x
EBITDA
Source: Axia Growth analysis of 4,554 closed small-business sales over $500K, aggregated and de-identified. Data as of 2026-10-28. Methodology.
Every size band has a published cell for the Financial Services sector.
Insurance broker M&A: who buys agencies and brokers?
Insurance broker M&A is driven by private-equity-backed brokers, national and regional brokers, and carriers buying distribution. They pay for commission revenue that renews, a clean book and producers who stay. Price follows size: in Axia Growth's Financial Services sector data, businesses with $10M+ of EBITDA sold for a median 9.0x EBITDA across 96 closed sales.
Source: Axia Growth analysis of 4,554 closed small-business sales over $500K, aggregated and de-identified. Data as of October 28, 2026.
The asset being bought is the agency's ownership of its expirations, meaning its renewal rights. The Independent Insurance Agents of Texas calls that ownership the essence of the independent agency system. That ownership is what makes an independent agency's renewal stream a saleable asset.
In Axia Growth's analysis of closed small-business sales, insurance agencies are grouped in the Financial Services sector, where businesses with $10M+ of EBITDA sold for a median 9.0x EBITDA (middle half 5.7x-14.4x) across 96 sales, updated October 28, 2026. According to MarshBerry, average upfront insurance agency valuations were 11.50x EBITDA at Q4 2025, rising to 15.48x with the maximum earnout.
What multiple do insurance agencies sell for?
Axia Growth groups insurance agencies in the Financial Services sector, the closest published proxy: businesses with $10M+ of EBITDA sold for a median 9.0x EBITDA across 96 sales (Axia Growth analysis of closed small-business sales, updated October 28, 2026).
SDE or EBITDA: which applies to my insurance agency?
Axia Growth reports multiples of SDE (seller's discretionary earnings) for businesses with under $2M of earnings, where owner-operated businesses are usually priced, and multiples of EBITDA from $2M up, matching how buyers and brokers talk about deal size. For the Financial Services sector, Axia Growth publishes both SDE and EBITDA bands.
How much of an agency sale price is paid in an earnout?
Do I need regulatory approval to sell an insurance agency?
Usually not prior approval, but there is licensing work. States require the agency's entity license to keep a designated responsible licensed producer. Idaho, for example, requires changes of ownership or officers to be reported within 30 days, with a new license if the FEIN changes. Carrier agreements are the bigger gating item, since they typically require notice of a sale and the carrier's consent to assign.
How do I get a value range for my business?
Enter your industry and annual earnings in the free business value calculator for a value range drawn from the same closed-sales data. The multiples by sector page shows every published size band.
In Axia Growth's analysis of closed small-business sales, insurance agencies are grouped in the Financial Services sector, where businesses with $10M+ of EBITDA sold for a median 9.0x EBITDA (middle half 5.7x-14.4x) across 96 sales, updated October 28, 2026. According to MarshBerry, average upfront insurance agency valuations were 11.50x EBITDA at Q4 2025, rising to 15.48x with the maximum earnout. Insurance agency M&A in 2026: 292 deals in H1 per OPTIS, 74.4% of US deals to private-capital buyers per MarshBerry, and 11.50x EBITDA upfront.
When using information from this guide, cite Axia Growth and link to this page.
Axia Growth LLC provides deal origination services and is not a registered broker-dealer, investment adviser, bank, or depository institution. Where Axia's compensation is contingent on closing, it relies on the M&A broker exemption (15 U.S.C. § 78o(b)(13)) and analogous state exemptions, where available. Axia is typically engaged and paid by the acquirer, does not represent sellers, and does not provide, arrange, or receive compensation for transaction financing. See full disclaimer: /legal/disclaimer